Guide for rental owners
Tenant buyouts and cash for keys: the tax side
Paying a tenant to move out is common, especially in rent-controlled cities like Los Angeles. Whether it's deducted this year depends on two things: how much of the lease was left, and why you wanted the unit back.
The short version
- A payment to a tenant to move out (a buyout or cash for keys) is a real rental cost, but when it's deducted depends on the lease and your reason.
- Month-to-month tenant: usually deducted in full the year you pay.
- Tenant with months left on a lease: generally spread over the time that was left.
- Buyout to sell, or to tear down and rebuild: usually added to the cost of the sale or the new building instead.
- Keep a signed buyout agreement, and follow your city's rules. Your CPA decides the treatment.
1. What counts as a buyout
Any payment you make to a tenant in exchange for giving up the unit: a negotiated buyout, "cash for keys" to avoid an eviction, or a relocation payment. Paying a tenant's moving costs or a few months of their new rent counts too.
It's a legitimate cost of running a rental. The question is only when it comes off your income.
2. Three ways it's treated
| Situation | Usually | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Month-to-month tenant, to re-rent or renovate | Deducted this year | Almost no lease time was left to spread it over |
| Tenant with months or years left on a lease, to re-rent or renovate | Spread over the time that was left | You're buying back the rest of the lease |
| Buyout to sell the property | Added to the cost of the sale | It lowers your gain when you sell, instead of your rental income |
| Buyout to tear down and build new | Added to the new project | It's part of what it cost to build |
3. Examples
Month-to-month
A long-time tenant on a month-to-month rental agrees to leave for $6,000 in October. You renovate and re-rent the unit. The $6,000 is generally deducted this year.
Lease with time left
A tenant has 10 months left on a lease and agrees to leave in October for $10,000. That's $1,000 per remaining month: about $3,000 deducted this year (October to December) and $7,000 next year.
Before a sale
You pay a tenant $15,000 to leave so you can sell the building vacant. It isn't deducted against rent; it's added to your selling costs, lowering the taxable gain by $15,000 when the sale closes.
4. Rent control and relocation payments
In rent-controlled cities, including the City of Los Angeles, buyouts and relocation payments are common and come with their own rules:
- Required relocation payments for no-fault evictions are treated much like buyouts, based on the reason: for a renovation and re-rental they're often deducted or spread over the lease; for a demolition or removing units from the rental market, usually added to the new project.
- Cities like Los Angeles may require a buyout disclosure given to the tenant and filed with the housing department. Follow your local rules and get legal advice for the agreement itself; this guide only covers the tax side.
5. Paperwork to keep
- The signed buyout agreement: amount, move-out date, and what each side agreed to.
- The lease, to show how much time was left (or that it was month-to-month).
- Proof of payment: check, transfer or receipt.
- A note on why you wanted the unit back, and what you did with it after.
- Any required city filings.
6. The tenant's side
For the tenant, a buyout is generally treated as money received for giving up their lease. Whether you need to send them a 1099 depends on the details, so ask your CPA before year-end. Don't hold back the payment over paperwork; just collect what you'll need (often a W-9) when you sign.
7. Your checklist
- Get the buyout agreement signed, with the amount and move-out date.
- Note whether the tenant was month-to-month or how much lease time was left.
- Write down why you wanted the unit back.
- Keep proof of payment and any city filings.
- Tell your CPA before year-end, including whether a 1099 is needed.
Questions to bring to your CPA
- "Can this buyout be deducted this year, or does it have to be spread over the rest of the lease?"
- "We plan to sell next year. Should the buyout go with the sale instead?"
- "Do I need to send the tenant a 1099?"
Tethered does this for you
Log a buyout in Tethered and it's flagged for your CPA with a plain-English note on how it might be treated, so the timing question gets settled before your return is filed. Attach the signed agreement as the receipt.
This guide is general information for rental owners, not tax advice. Tax rules change, and every situation is different; your CPA or tax advisor knows your full picture and decides how each cost is treated. Figures are estimates.