Guide for rental owners
Replaced a roof? You may be able to write off the old one
When a new roof goes on, the old one is often still on your books with years of depreciation left. Here's how landlords deduct that leftover value the same year, and why it has to be done on time.
The short version
- When you replace a roof, HVAC system, water heater or windows, the old one may still have value left on your depreciation schedule.
- A partial disposition lets you deduct that leftover value the same year, on top of starting depreciation on the new one.
- If the old part was never valued on its own, your CPA can use a reasonable estimate, usually worked back from the new part's cost.
- It's chosen by reporting it on that year's return. Miss the year and the chance is usually gone, so tell your CPA about every replacement.
- It's worth the most on buildings you've owned for many years.
1. Why the old roof is still on your books
When you bought your rental, the building's cost (minus the land) started depreciating over 27.5 years. That cost included the roof, the HVAC, the plumbing and everything else that's part of the building, even though nobody priced them separately.
Twelve years later you replace the roof for $28,800. The new roof starts its own 27.5-year schedule. But the old roof is still inside the original building cost, being depreciated as if it were still on the house. Without doing anything, you'd be depreciating two roofs, and the old one wouldn't be fully written off for another 15 years.
2. How a partial disposition works
A partial disposition tells the IRS: "this part of the building is gone." You take the old roof's remaining, not-yet-depreciated value out of the building's cost and deduct it as a loss that year.
- You get that deduction now, instead of slowly over the building's remaining years.
- The new roof is depreciated on its own schedule as normal.
- It's not a separate form. Your CPA reports the loss on the return for the year of the replacement, and that's the choice.
3. Estimating what the old one was worth
Almost nobody knows what their original roof cost; it was just part of the purchase price. The IRS allows a reasonable method. A common one:
- Start with what the new roof cost.
- Discount it back, using an inflation index, to the year the building went into service. That's an estimate of what the old roof cost back then.
- Subtract the depreciation already taken on that amount over the years you've owned it.
- What's left is the remaining value you can write off.
If you have better information, like a cost breakdown from your purchase or an earlier appraisal, your CPA may use that instead.
4. A worked example
Example
A building went into service in 2014. In 2026 the owner replaces the roof for $28,800.
Worked back to 2014 prices, the original roof is estimated at about $19,900. About 12 years of depreciation (roughly 42% of it) has already been taken, leaving about $11,500 on the books.
With a partial disposition, that $11,500 is deducted in 2026, worth about $4,000 in tax at a 35% rate, on top of the new roof's own depreciation. Without it, the same $11,500 trickles out over the next 15 years.
These are estimates; your CPA works out the real figure from your depreciation schedule.
5. The deadline
That's why the most important step is simply telling your CPA about every replacement, with the invoice, before your return is prepared.
6. What it works for
Any significant part of the building that you replace:
- Roofs (all or a large section)
- HVAC systems, furnaces and air conditioning units
- Water heaters and boilers
- Windows and doors replaced in quantity
- Flooring, cabinets and fixtures removed in a remodel
- Plumbing or electrical systems that are replaced
It matters less when you've owned the building only a year or two (little depreciation has been taken, so little gain from writing it off early) and for small items you'd deduct anyway.
7. Your checklist
- Keep the invoice for the new roof, HVAC or water heater, and note the date it was finished.
- Note what was removed: "tore off and replaced the entire roof," "replaced both 3-ton units."
- Give your CPA the year the building was placed in service and your depreciation schedule (or last year's return).
- Mention any tear-off or removal costs separately.
- Say whether insurance paid for any of it.
Questions to bring to your CPA
- "Can we take a partial disposition for the roof we replaced this year?"
- "What's your estimate of the old roof's remaining value?"
- "Can the tear-off cost be deducted now?"
- "Did we replace anything in earlier years that we should have written off?"
Tethered does this for you
Log a new roof, HVAC system or water heater in Tethered and it estimates what the old one was still worth, shows what writing it off could save, and adds the question to your CPA's list for that year, so the deadline isn't missed.
This guide is general information for rental owners, not tax advice. Tax rules change, and every situation is different; your CPA or tax advisor knows your full picture and decides how each cost is treated. Figures are estimates.